If you are stuck in such a situation, here is what to do.
Amelia and her partner, Leo, were having a tense discussion in a public park in the town of Oakhaven. Leo, who has been struggling with significant mental health issues, became overwhelmed and pushed Amelia, causing her to fall. Witnesses called the police, and Leo was arrested. During her initial conversation with the officers, a distressed Amelia mentioned that over a year ago, Leo had briefly strangled her during a different argument. Although she didn’t want to press charges and insisted it was a historical issue they were working through, the police took this information very seriously.
Leo was later released on police bail with strict conditions not to contact Amelia or visit their shared home for the next three months while the investigation continues. Amelia now regrets mentioning the past incident and is focused on getting private mental health support for Leo. She feels the bail conditions are preventing them from moving forward and wants to know if she, as the victim, can ask the police to cancel the bail.
Advice in such cases
In the UK, the decision to charge an individual with a crime rests with the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), not the victim. Even if the victim does not wish to support a prosecution, the police and CPS can proceed with an “evidence-led” prosecution if they believe it is in the public interest. Bail conditions are put in place by the police primarily to protect the victim and ensure the integrity of the investigation. A victim cannot unilaterally cancel or remove bail conditions, as the decision is not theirs to make. However, the victim’s views are an important factor that the police will consider.
- Consult with Lawyer: The very basic and important step to start is talk to Lawyer / advocate. You should not hesitate in paying his consultation fee i.e. might be in range of 100 GBP to 400 GBP depends case to case. He is helping you in this situation of come out. He is expert in the domain and can help you explain the procedure which you might have never explored.
Applicable Sections of Law
Several key pieces of UK legislation are relevant in these situations:
- The Bail Act 1976: This is the foundational law governing bail for suspects. It outlines the conditions under which police can grant pre-charge bail and the framework for court bail if a person is charged.
- The Domestic Abuse Act 2021: This landmark Act provides a statutory definition of domestic abuse that includes physical, emotional, coercive, or controlling behaviour, and economic abuse. It also created the specific criminal offence of non-fatal strangulation, reflecting its seriousness as an indicator of future harm.
- The Policing and Crime Act 2017: This Act reformed police bail, introducing a 28-day limit (which can be extended) and a presumption that a suspect will be “released under investigation” without bail, unless bail is necessary and proportionate. In domestic abuse cases, bail with conditions is often deemed necessary.
- Offences Against the Person Act 1861: This act covers relevant assault charges. A push could be a Common Assault, while the historical strangulation could be investigated as an Assault Occasioning Actual Bodily Harm (ABH) or even a more serious offence.
If you are the complainant
As the complainant (the person who has made the allegation or is the victim), your role is crucial, but it has limits. You can provide a statement to the police detailing the events. You can also express your wishes regarding the prosecution and the bail conditions. If you change your mind and no longer wish to support the case, you can inform the police. However, they may still proceed if other evidence exists (e.g., witness accounts, 999 calls, body-worn video).
If you are the victim
If you are the victim and wish to have bail conditions changed or removed, you cannot do it yourself. You must contact the police officer in charge of your case (the “OIC”). You can explain your reasons, for example, that you do not feel at risk and that the conditions are causing practical hardship or preventing access to support. The police have a duty to consider your views. However, they must balance this against their primary duty to protect you from potential harm. Given the mention of strangulation, which is a high-risk factor, the police will be very cautious about removing protective bail conditions.
How the police behave in such cases
UK police forces are trained to take domestic abuse allegations very seriously and to be proactive. They will often make an arrest to prevent an escalation of violence and to allow for a thorough investigation. They see bail conditions as a vital safeguarding tool. An allegation of strangulation will trigger a higher level of concern and will make them less likely to agree to remove conditions that separate the suspect from the victim, regardless of the victim’s wishes. Their goal is to manage the risk, and they will often err on the side of caution.
FAQs people normally have
- Can I withdraw my statement? You can inform the police that you wish to withdraw your support for the prosecution. This is often done via a formal retraction statement. While this may weaken the case, it does not automatically stop it. The CPS will review all other available evidence to decide if a prosecution is still viable and in the public interest.
- What happens if my partner breaches their bail conditions? Breaching pre-charge police bail is not a criminal offence in itself. However, it will almost certainly lead to the person being re-arrested. At that point, the police may decide to charge them with the original offence and either impose stricter bail conditions or hold them in custody to appear before a court.
- Can I be forced to testify in court? If the case proceeds to court and you are the main witness, you can be issued with a witness summons, which legally compels you to attend.
What evidence is required?
The police and CPS will gather a range of evidence, including:
- The victim’s detailed witness statement.
- Statements from any independent witnesses (e.g., the public in the park).
- Body-worn video footage from the responding police officers.
- Recordings of any 999 calls.
- Photographs of any injuries, no matter how minor.
- Medical records, if applicable.
- Digital evidence, such as text messages or social media posts relating to the incident.
How long will the investigation take?
The initial bail period, often for 28 days or extended to three months, is for the police to conduct their investigation. This involves interviewing the suspect, taking statements, gathering forensic evidence, and preparing a file. This file is then sent to the CPS for a charging decision. The entire process can take several months, depending on the complexity of the case and the workload of the police and CPS.
Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India
