# Trademark Objection Under Sections 9 and 11 for Proposed-to-Use Brand — What Worked in a Real Case

> Facing a trademark objection under Sections 9 and 11 with no prior sales? Learn the practical steps that helped a clothing brand secure acceptance after a hearing, and how domain-specific legal strate

Source: https://sudhirrao.com/insights/trademark-objection-section-9-11-proposed-to-use-solution  
Author: Sudhir Rao — Advocate, Supreme Court of India  
Category: Civil  
Published: 2026-07-28

---

#### One of my clients recently had a case which I am explaining below and if you are stuck in such similar situation, here is what to do.

**Note:** Due to attorney-client privilege, I cannot disclose complete case details or identify the actual parties involved. However, I am sharing the essential facts and legal approach so that if you find yourself in a similar situation, you can understand the available solutions and legal remedies.

**TL;DR:** A proposed-to-be-used trademark application for a new clothing brand faced objections under Sections 9 and 11. With no existing sales or invoices to show, the applicant built a digital and physical footprint—domain, social handles, Google Business, branded packaging, and a soft launch—before the hearing. Combined with a detailed legal reply distinguishing the cited marks, the application was accepted and published in the Trademark Journal.

 Mr. Arjun Mehta, an entrepreneur from Indore, had filed a trademark application under Class 25 for his upcoming clothing line, “UrbanTreads.” The brand was still in the pipeline—no products sold, no invoices, no market presence. The application was filed on a proposed-to-be-used basis. Soon, the examination report flagged two objections: the mark wasn’t distinctive enough under Section 9, and it allegedly conflicted with a couple of existing registrations under Section 11. Mr. Mehta initially consulted a lawyer with limited trademark experience. That lawyer drafted a routine reply, but the Registry scheduled a hearing, indicating the examiner wasn’t convinced. At this point, Mr. Mehta approached the Chamber of Advocate Sudhir Rao. The office of Advocate Sudhir Rao took a markedly different approach. Instead of relying solely on legal arguments about inherent distinctiveness, Advocate Sudhir Rao advised the client to immediately start building a verifiable commercial footprint around the mark—even before the hearing. The client registered the domain urbantreads.in, created Instagram and Facebook handles, listed the business on Google, printed branded tags and packaging, and conducted a small soft launch with a handful of sales. Every invoice, every post, every date-stamped photograph was meticulously preserved. At the hearing conducted virtually under Rule 115 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017, Advocate Sudhir Rao and his office argued that while the mark was not yet widely known, the evidence showed a real, nascent business—not just an idea. For the Section 11 objection, they demonstrated that the cited marks operated in entirely different sub-segments of clothing, through different trade channels, and that the overall commercial impression was distinct. The hearing officer agreed. The application was accepted and proceeded to publication in the Trademark Journal. The specialised handling—combining proactive brand-building with sharp legal distinction—turned a tough objection into a straightforward acceptance. 

# Key Facts of the Case

- Trademark application filed by Mr. Arjun Mehta for “UrbanTreads” (Class 25) on a proposed-to-be-used basis in early February 2025.
- Examination report raised objections under Section 9 (lack of distinctiveness) and Section 11 (conflict with prior marks).
- At the time of filing, there were zero sales, no invoices, and no online presence—making it difficult to prove the mark’s existence.
- Prior to the hearing, the client built a digital footprint: domain registration, social media handles, Google Business listing, branded packaging, and a soft launch with a few recorded transactions.
- Advocate Sudhir Rao’s office distinguished the cited marks by showing differences in target consumer, trade channels, and overall commercial impression.
- The hearing was held under Rule 115 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017, and the application was accepted and moved to the Trademark Journal.
- No opposition was filed, and the mark proceeded toward registration.

# The Direct Legal Answer

A proposed-to-be-used application facing Sections 9 and 11 objections is not a dead end. Section 9 looks at whether the mark can identify the source of the goods or services. The Registry often objects if the mark appears descriptive or common. But the question isn’t just about the mark’s inherent character—it’s about whether the mark *is capable* of distinguishing. By building a visible, date-stamped business presence around the mark before the hearing, you answer the Registry’s unspoken question: “Does this brand actually exist beyond the paper application?”

#### What about the Section 11 objection?

Section 11 deals with conflict with earlier marks. The test is whether the public is likely to be confused. Here, you can differentiate on class of goods—even within the same class—as well as trade channels, pricing, and the overall look and feel. The mere presence of a similar mark in the Register does not automatically mean refusal; a nuanced side-by-side breakdown often reveals the marks target different segments. The key is to present this comparison clearly and back it with whatever market reality you can show.

#### Can you survive an objection with no sales?

Yes—if you create enough corroborative material. Even a soft launch with a handful of transactions, supported by domain registration, social handles, branded stationery, and photographs, tells the examiner you are not merely holding a speculative filing. That shifts the discussion from “is it distinctive?” to “it is already functioning as a source identifier, and will only grow.”

# Advice in Such Cases

**Consult with Lawyer:** The very basic and important step to start is talk to Lawyer / advocate. You should not hesitate in paying his consultation fee i.e. might be in range of Rs. 10,000 to 50,000 depends case to case. He is helping you in this situation to come out. He is expert in the domain and can help you explain the procedure which you might have never explored. A good lawyer can get the issues resolved much faster than you think.

Don’t wait for the hearing notice. The moment you file, start building. Secure the domain and matching social handles. Create invoices even for small test sales. A trademark objector’s worst enemy is a pile of dated documents showing the mark in genuine use—no matter how modest. And here’s the thing—in proposed-to-be-used cases, the difference between an abandoned application and an accepted one often comes down to how vividly you can prove the mark’s commercial reality. General practitioners may miss the evidentiary nuance of Rule 115 hearings, where the examiner is not just reading your reply but testing your brand’s life. This type of matter benefits hugely from an advocate who routinely handles trademark prosecution.

# Applicable Sections of Law

- **Section 9 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999:** Absolute grounds for refusal—marks devoid of distinctive character, descriptive marks, or marks that have become customary in the trade.
- **Section 11 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999:** Relative grounds for refusal—conflict with earlier trademarks, including likelihood of confusion or association.
- **Rule 115 of the Trade Marks Rules, 2017:** Provides for the hearing before the Registrar when an objection persists after examination reply.
- **Section 18(5) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999:** Acceptance of application or refusal; the Registrar may accept with or without conditions after hearing.

# Limitation Period

There is no strict limitation period for responding to an examination report, but you must reply within one month of receipt to avoid deemed abandonment. That timeline can be extended through a formal request. Once the application is accepted and published, any third-party opposition must be filed within four months from the date of advertisement in the Trademark Journal. Missing that window means the mark proceeds to registration without opposition. The limitation clock for opposition starts from the date of publication, not the date of application.

# Interim Reliefs Available

Trademark prosecution doesn’t involve court-ordered interim reliefs like injunctions at the Registry stage. However, once the mark is registered—or even during the application period if the mark is used and faces infringement—you can approach a civil court for a temporary injunction under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, read with Section 135 of the Trade Marks Act. This can restrain the opposite party from using a deceptively similar mark. In proposed-to-be-used matters, this usually becomes relevant after registration, not before. But the evidence you build during prosecution—the same photos, invoices, and online presence—becomes the foundation for any future relief.

# If You Are the Victim

- If someone else’s similar mark is blocking your application, don’t panic. Collect detailed evidence of your use (if any) and demonstrate the differences.
- Check whether the cited mark is actually being used. A mark can be removed for non-use if it hasn’t been in genuine commercial use for five years and three months.
- Maintain strict date records of every single step—domain booking, first social post, first invoice date. These dates become anchors in your argument.
- Do not abandon your application without a hearing. A well-prepared hearing can salvage an application that a written reply couldn’t.
- If you suspect the objection is purely technical and the cited marks are dead, unchallenged, or in a different market niche, highlight that gap.

# Documents You Must Keep Ready

- Trademark application number and examination report.
- Domain registration confirmation (with date stamp).
- Screenshots of social media handles showing the mark and the creation date.
- Invoices of any sales, however small.
- Photographs of branded packaging, labels, stationery, products.
- Google Business listing screenshot.
- Printout of any soft-launch event, market testing, or pop-up store with dates.
- Correspondence with the Registry, including the reply already filed.

# What Evidence Is Required?

- Proof of adoption: the earliest date the mark was conceived or first used, even in a limited way.
- Sales invoices or order confirmations showing the mark in a commercial context.
- Promotional material: social media posts, advertisements, influencer content—all with visible dates.
- Third-party recognition: Google reviews, customer messages, any public mention of the brand.
- Comparative charts: side-by-side visuals of your mark versus the cited marks to highlight differences.
- Market research or search reports showing no actual confusion in your trade channel.
- Statutory declarations or affidavits affirming the facts, where necessary.

# How Courts Typically Approach Such Cases

Registrars and Intellectual Property Appellate Boards, and now the High Courts exercising writ jurisdiction, tend to lean in favor of allowing a mark to proceed to advertisement if there is even a prima facie case of distinctiveness and no glaring conflict. The policy is to let the mark be published so that any genuinely aggrieved party can oppose, rather than prematurely killing an application. Examiners often appreciate when an applicant has taken concrete steps to bring the mark to market—it demonstrates good faith. A common judicial observation is that trademark rights are acquired by use, not just registration. So even a nascent but genuine commercial effort carries weight.

# Timeline of Legal Process

- **Application filing:** Day 0. Examination report typically issues within 1–3 months.
- **Reply to examination report:** Within one month, extendable. Registry may accept or schedule a hearing if not satisfied.
- **Hearing notice:** Usually 1–2 months after reply. Hearing date set 15–30 days out.
- **Hearing:** Oral or video conference under Rule 115. Order typically passes within 15–30 days.
- **Acceptance and journal publication:** If accepted, published for opposition within a few weeks.
- **Opposition window:** Four months from publication. If none, registration certificate issues.
- **Total time from filing to registration (unopposed):** 8–14 months, depending on backlog.

# Understanding the Costs

The total cost of a matter like this varies significantly from one case to the next — it depends on the complexity of the dispute, the forum involved, the number of hearings, and the specific facts of your situation. There is no single fixed figure that applies to everyone.

A professional advocate can give you an accurate estimate only after reviewing all your facts and documents in a consultation.

# Can the Matter Be Settled Out of Court?

At the Registry stage, there is no “settlement” in the traditional sense, but you can file a request to amend the application—limiting the specification of goods or services to narrow the conflict. That sometimes resolves a Section 11 overlap. If a third party has already filed an opposition, mediation is possible and sometimes directed by the Registrar. The Commercial Courts Act encourages pre-institution mediation for disputes, and the Trademarks Act allows for opposition to be withdrawn based on mutual understanding. For brand owners, an amicable settlement—even co-existence agreements—can be a pragmatic way forward without years of litigation.

# Common Mistakes People Make

- Filing the trademark and then doing nothing for months, leaving zero evidence of use when the objection arrives.
- Assuming that a Section 9 objection is fatal without attempting to supply evidence of acquired distinctiveness through use, however recent.
- Comparing the marks too broadly—failing to drill down into specific sub-categories, trade channels, and consumer demographics.
- Engaging an advocate who does not regularly handle trademark prosecution work. The procedural strategy for Rule 115 hearings and the art of distinguishing marks require a practised eye that general practitioners may not develop.
- Ignoring the power of a soft launch. Even selling a few units to friends and documenting it transparently can transform the narrative at the hearing.
- Not photographing branded material with clear date stamps, leaving the examiner without tangible proof that the mark is active.
- Waiting until the last minute to prepare for the hearing instead of building the brand’s story from day one of filing.

# FAQs People Normally Have

#### Can I file a proposed-to-be-used mark when I haven't started the business?

Yes, the Trademarks Act specifically allows applications based on “proposed to be used.” You don’t need existing sales, but you must have a bona fide intention to use the mark. The hurdle is proving that intention when objections are raised.

#### What if I have no sales at all—can I still overcome Section 9?

Yes. You can rely on the inherent distinctiveness of the mark if it’s not directly descriptive. But supplementing with even minimal printouts, a registered domain, and social media presence greatly strengthens your case.

#### Do I need a lawyer for the hearing?

You can appear yourself, but the hearing officer’s questions are often nuanced. An advocate familiar with trademark prosecution can anticipate the examiner’s train of thought and present the distinctions more effectively.

#### Will the cited mark owners automatically get my application refused?

No. The cited marks are only an indication of possible conflict. You have the opportunity to argue dissimilarity. And even if the examiner maintains the objection, you can challenge it before the High Court.

#### How long does it take to get the registration certificate after journal publication?

If no opposition is filed within four months, the certificate usually issues within 4–8 weeks, depending on the Registry’s processing time.

*This article is general legal information, not legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate about your specific situation.*

*Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India*

---

_This is the AI-readable Markdown version of an article published by the Chambers of Sudhir Rao. It is general legal information, not legal advice. Canonical page: https://sudhirrao.com/insights/trademark-objection-section-9-11-proposed-to-use-solution_
