# Recovery Suit When a Friend Took a Loan in Your Name

> Recovery suit in India when a friend took a loan in your name and now denies it: WhatsApp evidence, Order 37 CPC, limitation periods and the practical steps.

Source: https://sudhirrao.com/insights/recovery-suit-friend-took-loan-in-your-name  
Author: Sudhir Rao — Advocate, Supreme Court of India  
Category: Civil  
Published: 2026-09-22

---

#### One of my clients recently had a case which I am explaining below and if you are stuck in such similar situation, here is what to do.

**Note:** Due to attorney-client privilege, I cannot disclose complete case details or identify the actual parties involved. However, I am sharing the essential facts

with names, places, dates and section numbers changed. The legal problem is the same one I see most weeks, and the steps below are the ones that actually matter.

## What to do in the first 72 hours

The first thing most people do is call someone who tells them not to worry. That is usually the costliest phone call of the whole matter. Whether the paper in your hand is a police notice, a summons, or a complaint filed by a business partner, the early moves set the shape of everything that follows.

Read the document twice before you discuss it with anyone. Once for what it says, once for what it leaves out. A notice that does not state an offence, a date, or the provision it is issued under is a different animal from one that does.

- Write down the exact date the notice, summons or FIR reached you. Not the date on the document. The date it reached you.
- Note the police station, court or authority named, and the section numbers quoted.
- Copy every deadline printed in the document into your phone calendar the same day.
- Keep the envelope, courier slip, or the original email with full headers. Do not forward it and delete the original.
- Preserve chats, call records, bank statements, invoices and any CCTV footage you control. Footage gets overwritten in weeks.
- Write one plain page of what happened, in order, with dates. Your own words, not a lawyer's. Bring that page to the first meeting.
- Do not post about it. Not a story, not a vague post, not a comment under a news article.

## Do not send a reply you have drafted yourself

A reply to a legal notice becomes evidence. If you write three paragraphs denying everything and get one date wrong, that date will be read out to you later. If you admit something casually — "yes, I did receive the payment but..." — you have handed over an admission you cannot take back.

The same applies to statements to the police. You are not obliged to answer questions during an investigation, and a statement made to a police officer during investigation is not signed and is not meant to be used as your evidence. Anything you say in a written complaint you file yourself, however, is a different matter entirely. That document is yours for the rest of the case.

## How a criminal case starts under the BNSS

Since 1 July 2024, the procedure is governed by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. An FIR for a cognizable offence is registered under Section 173 of the BNSS, which replaces Section 154 of the old Code of Criminal Procedure. The informant is entitled to a free copy of the FIR.

A few practical points that come up constantly:

- A police station cannot refuse an FIR because the offence happened outside its area. It registers what is often called a zero FIR and transfers the papers. Insist on registration and, if refused, ask for the refusal in writing.
- For offences punishable with three to seven years, the BNSS permits a short preliminary enquiry before an FIR is registered, with the prior permission of a superior officer. If you are on the receiving end of such an enquiry, the enquiry itself is a stage you should be represented at.
- Information can now be given electronically, but it has to be signed within three days. An unsigned electronic complaint is an incomplete record.
- If the police close a complaint without registering a case, the remedy is an application before the Magistrate seeking a direction to investigate. This is not a formality and the application has to be drafted carefully.

## If the police want to talk to you, or arrest you

Arrest is not the default. Section 35 of the BNSS, which replaces Section 41A of the old Code, requires a notice of appearance in most cases where arrest is not necessary. When arrest does happen, Section 47 requires the officer to tell you the grounds immediately, and you cannot be held beyond twenty-four hours without a Magistrate's order. Section 58 gives you the right to meet an advocate of your choice during interrogation. Use it. Ask for the lawyer before you answer anything, and say nothing in the car on the way to the station.

There is one more thing worth saying plainly. If you are arrested and the investigation is not finished within sixty days — ninety, for offences punishable with death, life imprisonment, or ten years or more — you have a right to be released on default bail. Courts take that deadline seriously. Police stations sometimes do not.

## Anticipatory bail and regular bail are not the same thing

If you have reason to believe you will be arrested, you apply for anticipatory bail under Section 482 of the BNSS, which replaces Section 438 of the old Code. If you have already been arrested, bail is sought before the Magistrate or, in the cases that qualify, the Sessions Court or the High Court.

Anticipatory bail is time-sensitive and fact-sensitive. Whether it is granted depends on the offence alleged, your history, whether you are likely to tamper with evidence, and which court you approach. I cannot tell you from here whether you will get it, and anyone who tells you otherwise before reading your papers is guessing.

## Electronic evidence: the certificate nobody remembers

A large share of modern cases turn on WhatsApp messages, emails, call detail records and CCTV. Under Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, electronic records produced as secondary evidence need a certificate in the prescribed form. Courts have been strict about this. If your case depends on a chat or a recording, that certificate has to be thought about at the start, not at the stage of arguments.

Practically, this means you should not reformat a phone, change a SIM, or clear a cloud backup while a dispute is live. Preserve the original device if you can.

## If the notice is a cheque bounce notice

Different statute, different clock. Under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, the payee must send the demand notice within thirty days of receiving the bank's dishonour memo. You then have fifteen days from receipt of the notice to pay. If the fifteen days pass without payment, the payee can file a complaint within the following month.

A reply is not compulsory. It is often still worth sending, because it fixes your version of events early. Do not sit on the fifteen days and then assume the matter has gone away.

## What I ask people to send before the first call

You do not need a full brief. You need three things, and they take ten minutes to assemble.

First, the notice, FIR, summons or complaint — a clear photograph of every page, including the back if anything is written there. Second, the date it reached you, and how. Third, a two-line note in your own words: what the dispute is about, and what you want to happen next.

Send that to **me@sudhirrao.com** or call **+91 97295 06771**. You can also use the form at [/contact-us](/contact-us) or book a slot at [/book](/book). Bring the original documents to the meeting if you have them.

For matrimonial and family matters, including proceedings that run alongside a criminal complaint, Adv. Jyoti Rao handles those briefs and can be reached through the same chamber.

On some facts there is very little to argue, and I will tell you that in the first meeting rather than in the fifth. That is more useful to you than a hearing you did not need.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Should I reply to a legal notice if I have done nothing wrong?

Usually yes, but the reply has to be drafted, not typed in anger. A silence can be read as acceptance in civil disputes. A badly drafted reply can be worse than silence. Get it looked at before it goes out.

### Can the police call me to the station just for questioning?

They can ask you to come. They cannot hold you beyond twenty-four hours without a Magistrate's order, and you are entitled to have a lawyer present during interrogation under Section 58 of the BNSS. Confirm the time and place in writing, and take the lawyer with you.

### How long does an FIR investigation take?

It varies. Straightforward cases often finish in a few months. Economic offence investigations routinely run past a year, and the ninety-day period for default bail is tied to the punishment prescribed, not to how long the police say they need.

### Is an FIR the same as a chargesheet?

No. The FIR is the starting record. The chargesheet is the report the police file after investigation, and it is on that report that the court decides whether to frame charges.

### What if the notice has no section number or date on it?

It may still be a valid notice, depending on what it asks for. Its defects are worth pointing out early rather than taking a chance on them later.

### Can I get the FIR quashed?

Sometimes. Quashing is an extraordinary remedy and the court looks at whether the allegations, taken at face value, even disclose the offence alleged. It is not a shortcut around a trial, and it should be assessed on the actual text of the complaint.

### Do I need to come to Delhi?

Not always. Most first consultations can be done over the phone or by video, and documents can come by email. Where the matter is listed in Delhi — the Supreme Court, the Delhi High Court, or a district court here — you will eventually have to appear, or send someone who can. Cases filed elsewhere are usually heard where they are filed, subject to what the BNSS and the specific statute allow on transfer. The chamber is at Chamber No. 86 in the Supreme Court complex, and that is the only office. There is no second address.

### Will the police arrest me if I cooperate?

Cooperation helps, but it is not a guarantee. The BNSS requires a notice of appearance in most cases where arrest is not necessary, and courts have repeatedly said that arrest cannot be routine. What actually moves the needle is the offence alleged and your conduct during the enquiry. Do not refuse to appear, and do not appear without a lawyer.

### Who pays for the lawyer?

You do, unless a court orders otherwise. Legal aid is available through the District Legal Services Authority if you qualify on income. Fee arrangements are discussed at the first meeting and confirmed in writing before any work starts. There are no hidden charges, and no one in this chamber will ask you for money up front over a phone call.

### The notice is in a language I don't read

Get a translation you can rely on, not a rough one from a friend. A mistranslated date or a missed condition changes the whole calculation of what you must do next. Send the original with the translation.

## One last thing

Where the papers show nothing worth arguing, I will say so at the first meeting. If the fifteen days under the Negotiable Instruments Act are running, or a summons has a return date, those deadlines do not pause while you decide. Send the document, the date it reached you, and two lines about what the dispute is, to **me@sudhirrao.com** or call **+91 97295 06771**. You can also use the form at [/contact-us](/contact-us) or book a slot at [/book](/book).

*This article is general information about Indian law as on the date of writing and is not legal advice on your own situation. Every case turns on its own documents and facts.*

*Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India*

---

_This is the AI-readable Markdown version of an article published by the Chambers of Sudhir Rao. It is general legal information, not legal advice. Canonical page: https://sudhirrao.com/insights/recovery-suit-friend-took-loan-in-your-name_
