Warranty Claim: What to Do When It's Refused
A warranty claim is usually refused in a thirty-second phone call. The one described to us was refused exactly that way: the damage, the service centre said, was not covered. There may have been an inspection. There was certainly a refusal, and the person who wrote in was left holding a service job sheet and a phone number that routed to a call centre rather than to anyone who could reverse the decision.
We have one side of this. The service centre's report is not in front of us, and the gap between "the product failed" and "the product was damaged" is often the entire case. So what follows is the law as it stands and the sequence that tends to matter — not a prediction about this particular claim.
Key facts that decide a warranty claim dispute
- What the warranty document actually promises, word for word.
- Whether it came from the seller, the manufacturer, or both.
- Whether the problem is a manufacturing defect or damage that happened after purchase.
- Whether the inspection was done in front of the owner or in a back room.
- Whether the refusal was given in writing, with reasons and the clause relied on.
- How much time has passed since the refusal — two years is the outer limit for a consumer complaint.
- Whether the seller made verbal promises at the point of sale that go beyond the printed card.
What a warranty is, legally
A warranty is a term of the contract of sale. The Sale of Goods Act, 1930 separates a condition from a warranty: a condition goes to the root of the contract, while a warranty is a collateral promise. Breach of a warranty gives you a right to compensation. It does not automatically give you the right to reject the goods and walk away.
Separately, Section 16 of that Act implies a condition that goods are reasonably fit for the purpose made known to the seller, and of merchantable quality, where the seller deals in goods of that kind. That implied condition operates whether or not a warranty card was printed. So when a manufacturer says "we cover only what is in the card", the card is not necessarily the the whole of the bargain.
That distinction matters in practice. A service centre reads the card. A commission reads the card, the invoice, the job sheet, the inspection report and Section 16 of the Sale of Goods Act together. Where the two conflict on quality, the statute usually wins.
When a refused warranty claim becomes a deficiency in service
Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, "deficiency" is defined in Section 2(11) as a fault, imperfection, shortcoming or inadequacy in the quality, nature or manner of performance that a person is required to maintain under a contract or under any law. Honouring a warranty that was sold with the product is part of that performance. Refusing it without a reason that holds up is where complaints begin.
Unfair trade practice
Section 2(47) of the Act lists what counts as an unfair trade practice. Two entries in that list are routinely used in warranty disputes: representing that goods are of a particular standard or quality when they are not, and refusing to take back defective goods or withdraw deficient services. If the box said one thing and the service centre said another, that is the clause to plead.
Product liability
Chapter VI of the Act deals with product liability — a claim against a manufacturer, a product service provider or a seller for harm caused by a defective product or a deficient service. It is a separate route from a plain deficiency complaint and it carries its own exceptions. For most warranty disputes the deficiency route is simpler and is the one usually taken.
Who do you file against — seller, manufacturer, or both?
You can array both. The seller is the person you had the contract of sale with; the manufacturer made the promise on the card. Joining both avoids the situation where the seller says "that is the company's warranty" and the company says "we have no contract with you".
If the purchase was made on an online marketplace, the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 place duties on the marketplace and on the seller listed on it. Whether the marketplace itself is liable turns on who the contract was with and how the listing described the warranty. This differs from case to case and there is no single answer.
How long do I have to file a warranty claim complaint?
Two years. Section 69(1) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 gives you two years from the date the cause of action arose — in a warranty dispute, typically the date of refusal, not the date of purchase. Section 69(2) allows a commission to condone a delay for sufficient cause, but do not build a case on condonation.
Jurisdiction is layered by value. District Commissions hear claims up to ₹50 lakh, State Commissions from ₹50 lakh to ₹2 crore, and the National Commission above ₹2 crore. Territory is decided by where you live or work, or where the opposite party has an office.
What the process looks like, step by step
- Before filing: a written complaint to the seller or manufacturer, asking for the refusal to be put in writing with the clause relied on. Keep proof you sent it.
- Filing: a complaint under Section 35, with an affidavit, the documents, and the prescribed fee. Most commissions accept e-filing through the e-Daakhil portal; a physical filing counter also exists.
- Admission and notice: the commission decides whether there is a case to answer, then issues notice to the opposite party, who files a written version.
- Evidence: both sides file affidavits and documents. Where the defect itself is disputed, the commission can direct that the product be sent for testing by a laboratory and the report is given to both sides, who may object to it.
- Order: the commission may direct repair, replacement, refund, compensation for the loss suffered, and costs. The Act asks commissions to try and decide within three months where no testing or expert evidence is needed, and five months where it is. Contested matters run longer.
- Appeal: an appeal lies to the State Commission within 45 days of the order.
A legal notice before filing is customary, not mandatory. It usually produces a better paper trail than a settlement.
What actually decides these cases
The refusal letter. A written refusal that cites no clause and no inspection finding is hard to defend. A written refusal that cites a specific exclusion and a specific observation — liquid damage, physical impact, unauthorised repair — is much harder to attack.
Then the inspection. If the product was opened in a back room and you never saw what was found, say so, and ask for the photographs and the technician's notes. If you were present and the technician pointed at something, that is evidence too, and it cuts the other way.
Then the timeline. A defect that appears days after purchase is treated differently from the same defect appearing eleven months in. Under Section 16 of the Sale of Goods Act the buyer generally has to show the goods were not of merchantable quality, and proximity in time is how that is usually shown.
Before you file, do these things
- Do not hand the product to a local repair shop first. That usually ends the warranty argument on its own.
- Photograph the product, the serial number, the invoice and the job sheet.
- Ask for the refusal in writing, addressed to you, naming the clause relied on.
- Keep the original warranty card or the online listing that described the warranty.
- Do not sign a settlement or a "no further claim" line to get the product back, unless you accept that is the end of it.
- Reply to emails and calls, even briefly. Silence is read as agreement.
When there may be nothing to argue
Some refusals are correct. Physical damage, liquid ingress, voltage damage, repairs by an unauthorised person, use outside the stated conditions, or an expired warranty period — each of these is a genuine answer, and a complaint on those facts usually fails and costs you time. The same is true where the "warranty" was only a verbal assurance at the counter that nobody else heard.
It is also worth saying that the warranty card is not the only thing you can rely on, but it is usually the strongest thing. Where the terms are genuinely clear and the exclusion genuinely applies, the honest advice is that there is little to pursue.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a refused warranty claim a consumer case or a civil suit?
Either, but the consumer route is cheaper and faster for most people. A civil suit for breach of warranty under Section 59 of the Sale of Goods Act is available — you can claim damages, or set up the breach in reduction of the price — but it carries court fees and a longer timeline. Where the value is modest, the District Commission is the practical forum.
Can the service centre charge an inspection fee?
They can charge what the terms of service say they can charge. What they cannot do is charge for a repair you did not authorise, or hold the product hostage against a payment you have disputed. Ask for the estimate in writing before any work starts.
I signed the job sheet. Does that end it?
Not automatically. A job sheet is usually an acknowledgement of receipt and of the reported complaint, not a waiver of your rights. If it contains a line waiving claims, that line may be challenged, but expect the opposite party to lean on it and expect to have to explain the circumstances in which you signed.
The product was a gift. Can I complain?
Possibly. The definition of "consumer" in the Act includes a user of the goods using them with the approval of the person who bought them. So a gift recipient can qualify, though the invoice and the buyer's details will be needed. The buyer is the cleaner complainant if they are willing to be named.
Can I demand a replacement instead of a repair?
It depends on what the warranty promises and how serious the defect is. Where the defect cannot be cured, or has recurred after repair, a commission can order replacement or refund. Where it is a minor defect capable of repair, the usual order is repair.
Do I need a lawyer for a warranty claim?
No. The consumer forums are designed to be used without one, and many complainants appear in person. A lawyer helps most where the amount is large, the defect is technical, or the opposite party has already engaged counsel.
What to send us
If you want this looked at, send a short note with: the invoice or order confirmation, the warranty document or the listing page that described the warranty, the job sheet, any written refusal, and photographs of the product and the damage. Two lines on what happened and when is enough to start.
Write to /contact-us or book a slot at /book. If on these facts there is nothing worth arguing, you will be told that in the first reply.
This is general information about Indian law and is not legal advice on your own situation. Every warranty dispute turns on its own documents.
Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India