# False FIR Threat After Breakup? Legal Options

> Threatened with a false FIR or suicide if you end a relationship? Know your legal options in India, what evidence to keep, and how anticipatory bail works.

Source: https://sudhirrao.com/insights/false-fir-threat-breakup-legal-options  
Author: Sudhir Rao — Advocate, Supreme Court of India  
Category: Criminal  
Published: 2026-09-20

---

#### One of my clients recently had a case which I am explaining below and if you are stuck in such similar situation, here is what to do.

**Note:** Due to attorney-client privilege, I cannot disclose complete case details or identify the actual parties involved. However, I am sharing the essential facts and legal approach so that if you find yourself in a similar situation, you can understand the available solutions and legal remedies.

**TL;DR:** Ending a consensual relationship between two adults is not a crime in India, and no FIR can stand on that fact alone. But a threat to file a false complaint, and a threat of self-harm, are two separate problems with two separate legal answers. The man facing this should stop negotiating in panic, preserve every message, and get advice before a complaint is registered rather than after it.

The first message came at 11:40 on a Tuesday night. Karan Malhotra was in Pune, between jobs, and he had already told Shreya twice, calmly, that he wanted to end the relationship. Her reply was that if he stopped answering, she would call his parents, then the neighbours, then the police.

They had been together about two years. Both are adults, and everything between them was consensual. When it soured, Karan did what most people do: he tried to withdraw slowly and hoped it would pass on its own. It didn't. The threats grew specific. First an FIR. Then a claim about a promise of marriage. Then a voice note he kept, saying she would end her life and it would be his fault.

He stopped sleeping. He was scared of the police and equally scared of what she might do to herself. An advocate he consulted locally told him to wait and watch. That advice cost him three weeks, and by then a complaint had been filed.

He then approached the Chamber of Advocate Sudhir Rao. The approach was different from day one: preserve everything, stop replying in panic, and treat the two risks as separate problems rather than one. When the complaint was registered, Advocate Sudhir Rao and his office moved for protection at the bail stage, and the Sessions Court granted it. Advocate Sudhir Rao's familiarity with this category of matter, where the criminal allegation and the mental-health risk have to be handled on separate tracks, is what secured the relief in Karan's favour. The investigation did not end in a chargesheet.

# Key Facts of the Case

- The relationship lasted roughly two years, between two consenting adults, and the physical relationship was consensual throughout.
- Karan had told her clearly and repeatedly that he wanted to end it; she did not accept the decision.
- The threats were specific: contact his parents and neighbours, file an FIR, claim there had been a promise of marriage, and harm herself if he did not continue the relationship.
- The suicide threat was recorded in a voice note, which Karan still had on his phone.
- A local advocate advised him to wait and watch. Three weeks later, a complaint was registered.
- The complaint was registered first. Bail protection was sought after, at the Sessions Court, and was granted.
- The investigation did not end in a chargesheet being filed in that matter.

One caveat before the law: this is a one-sided account. Whatever the investigating officer wrote down, and whatever Shreya would say, we do not have here. Read the rest as the legal framework that applies to these facts as described, not as a verdict on the people.

## The Law on Ending a Relationship, in One Line

Two adults in a consensual relationship are free to walk away. No consent, and no law, requires one of them to stay. Refusing to marry someone, or refusing to continue seeing them, is not an offence under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 or under anything else.

What creates criminal liability is not the breakup. It is a specific allegation about how the relationship was conducted — false promise of marriage, deceit, coercion, or a threat. If none of those exist on the facts, there is nothing to prosecute, and a court can say so.

## Can a Girlfriend File an FIR if You Refuse to Marry Her?

She can walk into a police station and complain. The police must then decide what offence, if any, the complaint discloses. Registration is not the same as a sustainable case.

The Supreme Court has repeatedly dealt with the "false promise of marriage" allegation in cases such as *Uday v. State of Karnataka*, *Deepak Gulati v. State of Haryana*, *Pramod Suryabhan Pawar v. State of Maharashtra* and *Dhruvaram Murlidhar Sonar v. State of Maharashtra*. The thread running through them is that the promise must have been false *at the time it was made*. A man who genuinely intended to marry and later changed his mind, or whose relationship simply broke down, has not committed an offence. A woman who consented knowing the relationship might not end in marriage had not consented on a misconception of fact.

That is the legal test. Whether it applies depends entirely on the messages, the timeline and both versions of what was said.

### The one provision that does exist

Section 69 of the BNS creates an offence of sexual intercourse obtained by deceitful means, or by a promise to marry made without any intention of fulfilling it. It carries imprisonment that can extend to ten years, and a fine. This replaced the older provisions on cohabitation induced by deceit. It is a real provision and it is being used. It is also not a provision that applies to a relationship that was consensual throughout and simply ended.

If the complaint names Section 69, the fight is about intent at the time of the promise — and that fight is won or lost on the chat history, not on argument.

## The Threat to File a False Complaint

Threatening someone with a false criminal case is criminal intimidation. In the BNS, that is Section 351, which corresponds to the old Section 506 of the Indian Penal Code. The basic offence carries up to two years; where the threat is of death or grievous hurt, the punishment is higher.

Practically, though, be realistic. A police station will rarely register an FIR because someone said "I will complain against you." Threatening to go to the police is not automatically intimidation, because going to the police is a lawful act. It only becomes intimidation if what is threatened is demonstrably false and used as leverage.

Where the threats are repeated, and where there is a demand for money or property to make them stop, that moves into extortion territory under Section 308 of the BNS. Save those messages. They are the ones that change the shape of the case.

## The Threat of Self-Harm

This is the part that most people get wrong, and it is the part that kept Karan awake.

Attempting suicide is not a punishable offence in India. Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 removed criminal liability for a person who attempts suicide, on the reasoning that such a person needs care, not prosecution.

What remains is abetment of suicide under Section 108 of the BNS. For abetment, there must be instigation, conspiracy or intentional aid — a positive act that pushed the person towards the act. Declining to continue a relationship is not instigation. Asking someone, calmly and in writing, to stop contacting you is not instigation either. Courts have consistently held that abetment requires something far more than an ordinary, even hurtful, end to a relationship.

That said, a threat of self-harm is not a bluff to be ignored. The right response is to pass the information on — to her family, a friend, or a mental health professional — in writing, once, factually, without accusation. Then step back. A man who keeps responding to suicide threats to prevent them is being held in the relationship by exactly the mechanism the threats were designed to create.

## Where the Other Provisions Fit — and Where They Do Not

- **Section 85 of the BNS** (cruelty by a husband or his relatives) applies only to a husband and his family. A boyfriend or ex-boyfriend cannot be charged under it, however bad the relationship was.
- **The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005** covers a "domestic relationship", which includes a relationship in the nature of marriage — but it requires the parties to have lived together in a shared household. A couple who never lived together generally falls outside it. Where they did share a home, the Act does apply and the remedies are civil in nature.
- **Maintenance** under Section 144 of the BNSS is available to a wife, and in defined circumstances to a woman in a marriage-like relationship. It is not a route open to a woman in an ordinary dating relationship that has ended.
- **Section 78 of the BNS** (stalking) is drafted with a woman as the person aggrieved. A man being pursued with calls and messages generally has to proceed under the general provisions instead — criminal intimidation, intentional insult, or defamation under Section 356 of the BNS if false statements are published.

## What Happens Once a Complaint Is Filed

The sequence is predictable, and knowing it removes half the panic.

1. **A complaint is received.** For offences punishable between three and seven years, Section 173(3) of the BNSS permits the police to conduct a preliminary enquiry to see whether a prima facie case exists, to be completed within fourteen days. Not every complaint becomes an FIR that day.
2. **An FIR is registered** under Section 173 of the BNSS. If the complaint is filed at a station without jurisdiction, a zero FIR is registered and transferred.
3. **Notice of appearance** under Section 35 of the BNSS may be served instead of an arrest. This is the codification of the rule in *Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar* — arrest is not automatic for offences punishable with up to seven years. If a notice arrives, the date on it is a real deadline. Do not miss it.
4. **Your statement is recorded** under Section 180 of the BNSS. You are entitled to have a lawyer present during questioning. Ask for the questions in writing if you are being asked to sign anything.
5. **Arrest, if it happens,** brings you before a Magistrate within twenty-four hours, and to the bail stage under Section 480 of the BNSS.

### Bail, before and after

If an FIR is registered and you fear arrest, the application is for anticipatory bail under Section 482 of the BNSS at the Sessions Court or the High Court. The principles are still those set out in *Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab*. In this category of case, the usual conditions asked for are that you will not contact the complainant, will not leave the jurisdiction without permission, and will join the investigation when called.

If a chargesheet is filed on facts that do not disclose an offence, or where the dispute is essentially private and the relationship was consensual throughout, the remedy is quashing under Section 528 of the BNSS, the successor to Section 482 of the CrPC. The categories in *State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal* still govern that jurisdiction. That is a High Court remedy, and it takes months, not weeks.

## What to Do Right Now — In This Order

1. **Stop replying.** Not rudely, not with a final message, not with an explanation. Every message you send after the threats begin is evidence that will be read in the worst possible light. One factual line, if anything: that you consider the relationship over and ask not to be contacted.
2. **Do not delete anything.** Not the chats, not the voice notes, not the call logs. Deleting looks like destruction of evidence, and it cannot be undone. Back everything up to a cloud account she cannot access.
3. **Preserve it properly.** For electronic records to be relied on in court, Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 requires a certificate in the prescribed form along with the device or the record. Take screenshots that show the full thread with visible timestamps and the contact name, not cropped fragments. Handsets are routinely sent for forensic examination.
4. **Write a chronology.** Dates, times, what was said, what was threatened, who else saw or heard it. Two pages, factual, no adjectives. This document is the single most useful thing you can hand a lawyer.
5. **Do not pay anything.** If money is demanded to withdraw the complaint, that is not a settlement, and it will not be the last demand.
6. **Do not sign a compromise under pressure.** An agreement extracted by threat has no standing, and it does not prevent a fresh complaint later.
7. **Engage counsel before the notice arrives, not after. **Engage counsel before the notice arrives, not after.** A matter like this is cheapest to fix at the stage where there is only a complaint. Once a notice under Section 35 of the BNSS is in your hand, the calendar starts running and your options narrow.**

## What This Actually Costs You in Time

People ask this first and are usually given an answer that is either too optimistic or not an answer at all. So, plainly, and with the caveat that courts vary:

- **Preliminary enquiry, where the police choose to hold one:** fourteen days, as Section 173(3) of the BNSS prescribes, though extensions do happen in practice.
- **Anticipatory bail:** the application can be moved immediately once there is a reasonable apprehension of arrest. Sessions Court hearings are often listed within days. If it goes to the High Court, weeks.
- **Investigation:** this is the part nobody can predict. Three months is common. A year is not unusual.
- **Quashing under Section 528 of the BNSS:** months at the High Court, sometimes more than a year, and the court may decline to interfere if the facts are disputed.

If someone promises you a fixed timeline, treat it as sales talk.

## Mistakes That Turn a Defence Into a Problem

Most of the damage in these matters is self-inflicted, and it happens in the first fortnight.

- **Replying after the threats begin.** Long messages explaining yourself get read as evidence of guilt or of a continuing relationship. Short ones read better. Silence reads best.
- **Deleting chats** because they are embarrassing. Embarrassment is survivable. A deleted thread looks like destruction of evidence and there is no way back from that.
- **Paying money to make it stop.** The first payment is never the last, and it converts a defence into an admission that something needed settling.
- **Assuming that because you are innocent nothing will happen.** Innocence is decided at trial, years later. The arrest, the notice, the weeks off work — those happen long before.
- **Handling it yourself out of shame.** This category of matter is common. Your lawyer has seen it.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Is ending a relationship a crime in India?

No. Two consenting adults can end a relationship, and one of them refusing to marry the other is not an offence under the BNS, 2023 or any other law. What can be an offence is a specific allegation — a false promise of marriage made without intent to keep it, deceit, coercion, or a threat. If none of that is on the facts, there is nothing to prosecute.

### Can a girlfriend file an FIR if I refuse to marry her?

She can file a complaint, and the police will record it. Whether it becomes an FIR, and whether a chargesheet follows, depends on whether the complaint discloses an offence. Refusal to marry, on its own, discloses none. The Supreme Court's line of decisions on false promise of marriage turns on intent at the time the promise was made, and that is proved or disproved from messages and the timeline, not from the complaint alone.

### Can I be arrested without an FIR being registered?

For offences punishable up to seven years, arrest is not routine — that principle, from *Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar*, is now reflected in Section 35 of the BNSS, under which a notice of appearance is ordinarily served instead. If a notice reaches you, the date on it is a real date. Appearing on it is not the same as admitting anything.

### What if she threatens to end her life?

Take the threat seriously as a welfare matter, not as a legal one. Attempting suicide is not punishable in India after Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017. Abetment of suicide under Section 108 of the BNS requires instigation, conspiracy or intentional aid — declining to continue a relationship does not meet that bar. Pass the information to her family or a professional in writing, once, factually, and then step back from the negotiation.

### Should I file a counter-complaint against her threats?

Sometimes, yes — repeated threats and a demand for money can be pursued under Section 351 or Section 308 of the BNS. But it is a decision to take with counsel, not in anger. A counter-complaint filed early can harden the other side and make the quashing of the main case harder. It is also worth knowing that a police station will rarely register an FIR on a bare "I will complain against you," because complaining to the police is itself a lawful act.

### Will I have to go to the police station alone?

You are entitled to have a lawyer present during questioning, and you should. Statements under Section 180 of the BNSS are recorded by the investigating officer. Read anything before you sign it, and ask for a copy.

### Can the whole thing be quashed?

Where the relationship was consensual throughout and the complaint does not disclose an offence, a petition under Section 528 of the BNSS at the High Court is the remedy. It is not a quick one, and courts will not interfere where the facts are genuinely disputed and need evidence. On thin or doubtful facts, it may be that a quashing petition is premature and the better course is to answer the investigation and wait. That is a call to make after reading the actual complaint, not before.

## What to Send, and Where

If you are in this position now, do not write a long narrative. Send three things:

1. A copy of the complaint, the FIR, or the notice — whichever you have, with its date.
2. A two-line note: when the relationship ended, and the first date on which a threat of an FIR or of self-harm was made.
3. A phone number and a time you can speak.

Do not send screenshots until someone asks for them. Do not send anything after ten at night because you cannot sleep — the messages will still be there in the morning, and so will the case.

You can reach the chamber through the [contact page](/contact-us), or fix a time directly at [/book](/book). The first conversation is about reading what you have and telling you honestly where you stand, including if the answer is that there is very little to argue on the facts as they are.

*This is general information about Indian law, not legal advice on your own situation. Every matter turns on its own facts and the documents.*

*Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India*

---

_This is the AI-readable Markdown version of an article published by the Chambers of Sudhir Rao. It is general legal information, not legal advice. Canonical page: https://sudhirrao.com/insights/false-fir-threat-breakup-legal-options_
