One of my clients recently had a case which I am explaining below and if you are stuck in such similar situation, here is what to do.
Note: Due to attorney-client privilege, I cannot disclose complete case details or identify the actual parties involved. However, I am sharing the essential facts and legal approach so that if you find yourself in a similar situation, you can understand the available solutions and legal remedies.
TL;DR: A refund does not switch off a criminal complaint by itself. But before an FIR is registered, the investigating officer has limited ground to keep a file alive when there is no offence made out and the complainant has withdrawn in writing. Once an FIR exists, closure or withdrawal needs the court, usually through compounding or a quashing petition.
Key Facts of the Case
- A used smartphone was sold through a second-hand e-commerce platform to a buyer in another city.
- The buyer alleged the handset was refurbished and passed off as new; the seller was hospitalised when the first messages arrived.
- The seller offered a full refund and asked for the phone back by courier.
- Before the courier moved, the buyer filed a complaint on the national cyber crime portal.
- The full amount was refunded and the payment was settled; the buyer then gave a written request to withdraw at the cyber police station.
- No FIR had been registered at that stage. The investigating officer refused to accept the withdrawal and asked for a court order.
- The matter was ultimately closed without an FIR after a documented written representation.
The Direct Legal Answer
You do not need a court order to close something that was never registered as an FIR. That is the short answer, and it is the point most investigating officers gloss over.
Can the IO refuse to close the complaint?
He can refuse to act on a withdrawal letter, because a complainant cannot unilaterally end a cognizable investigation. But where no FIR exists and no prima ...no prima facie case of a cognizable offence is made out, there is no investigation to stop. An order is a document you need when a court is already seized of a file. Here, there was no file.
What the complainant's withdrawal actually does
A complainant is not the prosecutor. He cannot wind up a criminal case by writing a letter, and he cannot resurrect one the same way. What his letter does is remove the only person with a grievance. Continue reading the file after that, and you are left with an investigating officer, a refund receipt, and a courier airway bill for a phone that has gone back.
What the law says before an FIR exists
Under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the police begin with information about a cognizable offence under Section 173 BNSS — the provision that replaced Section 154 CrPC. Lalita Kumari v. State of Uttar Pradesh settled that registration is mandatory when the information discloses a cognizable offence, and equally that where it does not, the police are under no obligation to register.
Section 173(3) BNSS is new and it matters here. It allows a preliminary enquiry — with the prior permission of the Superintendent of Police and within a limited time — for offences punishable with three to seven years, to decide whether a prima facie case exists. Cheating under Section 318 BNS (the old Section 420 IPC) sits in that band. Cheating by personation using a computer resource under Section 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000 carries up to three years.
So the sequence is short. A preliminary enquiry, then a fork: FIR, or closure. Nothing in that fork requires a magistrate's signature.
Can a cyber crime complaint be withdrawn after a refund?
Two different questions hide inside that one, and the answer flips depending on which you are asking.
- Before an FIR is registered: there is nothing to withdraw, strictly speaking. The complaint sits with the cyber police as an enquiry. A written withdrawal from the complainant, with proof of refund, gives the officer the material he needs to close it. He is not bound by it, but on facts like these he has little to hold on to.
- After an FIR is registered: the complainant's letter is worth almost nothing on its own. Once an FIR exists, only the court can end the case, through compounding or a quashing petition.
If a cyber crime complaint is withdrawn after refund and no FIR follows, that is usually the end of it on the criminal side. The seller's exposure does not vanish entirely — a buyer can still sue for the price of the phone, or for damages. But that is a civil claim, and it is a different fight.
If an FIR has already been registered
Get the date of registration and the section mentioned in it. Everything downstream turns on those two things and on how far the investigation has travelled.
Quashing under Section 528 BNSS
The High Court's inherent power, earlier Section 482 CrPC, is the broadest route. State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal lists the categories in which a criminal proceeding can be quashed — including where the dispute is essentially civil in nature and has been given a criminal colour. Gian Singh v. State of Punjab deals with quashing on the basis of settlement in private disputes. Both are frequently cited in exactly this kind of matter, and both are also frequently distinguished. A quashing petition on a commercial dispute is not automatic, and courts do not treat the mere return of money as an eraser.
Compounding under Section 359 BNSS
Offences of this kind — cheating, where the loss can be measured in money — are generally compoundable with the permission of the court. Compounding is a cleaner route than quashing when the parties have genuinely settled and the amount has moved. It requires the complainant to appear and consent.
Anticipatory bail under Section 482 BNSS
If arrest is a live worry, this is a separate application and it is heard on its own footing. Do not treat the refund as a reason to skip it.
If you get a notice under Section 35 BNSS
That is the old Section 41A CrPC notice to appear. Appear. Do not send a cousin, do not send a WhatsApp reply instead, and do not skip it. Go with counsel, and remember that you are not obliged to answer questions that expose you to a criminal charge.
What the refund changes, and what it does not
Returning the money is restitution. It does not, by itself, mean no offence was committed at the time it was committed. Where the allegation is that a handset was refurbished and sold as new, the refund repairs the loss — it does not settle whether the representation was dishonest. Courts say this in different ways, but the point is consistent: money back is a strong mitigating fact, not an automatic defence.
What the refund does do is strip the complainant of his reason to push. That is why these files usually go quiet.
Records to keep — Section 63 BSA, 2023
Electronic records have their own rule now, under Section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, which replaced Section 65B of the Evidence Act. Keep:
- The NCRP complaint number and a screenshot of the filed complaint.
- The full message thread with the buyer, unedited — not selected screenshots.
- The product listing as it stood when you posted it, with the condition description.
- Bank or UPI proof of the refund, with the reference number.
- The courier receipt and tracking history for the returned handset.
- The buyer's written withdrawal, and a stamp or acknowledgement of the day it was handed over at the police station.
- Your own written representation asking for closure, with the acknowledgement copy.
Keep the device on which the messages were exchanged. A printout of a chat is not the same thing as the record the court may want to see.
What happens first, and how long it takes
The first step is always documentary. A written request to the investigating officer, copied to the Superintendent of Police, enclosing the refund proof and the buyer's withdrawal, asking for a formal closure intimation. Expect two to six weeks, depending on the station. A preliminary enquiry under Section 173(3) BNSS is time-bound, and once it runs its course without an FIR, the file has nowhere to go.
A quashing petition is a different clock. Filing to first hearing is usually weeks, not months, but a contested disposal can take a year or more. Compounding is faster where the complainant cooperates and appears.
When there may be nothing to argue
If the listing described the phone's condition accurately and the buyer simply changed his mind, you have a defence and the record proves it. If the listing was silent or evasive about the phone being refurbished, the refund helps on sentence and on settlement, but it does not erase the misrepresentation. If the refund was conditional — paid only after the buyer agreed to withdraw — say so, because that is a fact in your favour and courts read it that way. And if the buyer took the money and then went silent without filing anything, sometimes there is genuinely nothing to do except keep the papers and wait.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a court order to close a cyber crime complaint where no FIR was registered?
No. There is no proceeding for a court to close. A court order is needed only after an FIR exists.
Will the police close the case if the complainant gives a withdrawal letter?
They can. The complainant cannot force them, but where there is no offence left to investigate and the only aggrieved person has withdrawn in writing, there is usually nothing to pursue. Get the closure in writing anyway, even if it is one line on your representation.
Does the refund itself end the case?No. It ends the buyer's reason to pursue, which is not the same thing. Whether an offence was committed is judged as at the time of the sale, and returning the money afterwards is treated as restitution — a strong fact on sentence and on settlement, not an automatic defence.
Can the buyer file a fresh complaint after withdrawing?
He can try. In practice a second complaint on the same facts, after a written withdrawal and a refund, is not attractive to an investigating officer, and a court looking at it will want to know why the first one ended. Keep the withdrawal letter safe for exactly this reason.
Should I worry about arrest while the enquiry is on?
A Section 35 BNSS notice is not an arrest. If you receive one, appear with counsel. If arrest looks likely — usually because the amount is large or the buyer is pushing hard — anticipatory bail is a separate application under Section 482 BNSS and should not be skipped on the assumption that the refund has cooled things down.
What if the buyer takes the money and refuses to withdraw?
Then the file stays open on paper. Put your version on record in writing, with the refund proof attached, and ask for a closure intimation. If an FIR is later registered, the refund and the correspondence become your material for quashing or compounding.
Can I settle it civilly instead?
Yes, and often that is the sensible end. A short written settlement recording the refund, the return of the handset and the withdrawal of the complaint is worth more than a chain of messages. Have it signed by both sides.
What to send, and where
If a cyber crime complaint has been filed against you and a refund has already moved, the papers decide the file. Send these, in this order:
- The complaint or notice, with its date and the police station or portal reference number.
- The product listing as it stood, and the full message thread with the buyer.
- Proof of the refund — bank or UPI reference, and the date it was credited.
- The courier receipt for the returned handset, if it has gone back.
- Any withdrawal letter from the buyer, signed and dated.
- Two lines in your own words: what was sold, when, and what has happened since.
Anything that has already been filed or served — an FIR copy, a Section 35 BNSS notice, a court summons — should come first, because the date on it decides what is still open to you. Write to /contact-us or /book with the documents attached. If the enquiry is still at the police station stage and no FIR has been registered, say so in the first line, because that single fact changes the advice entirely.
On some of these files there is genuinely nothing to argue — the listing was accurate, the buyer changed his mind, the money is back. That is worth knowing early, and it is cheaper to hear it now than after a quashing petition.
This article is general information about Indian law and is not legal advice on your own situation. Please consult an advocate with your documents before acting.
Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India
Facing a similar matter? Speak to a criminal advocate in Delhi — Advocate Sudhir Rao appears in bail, trial and appellate matters before the Delhi District Courts, the Delhi High Court and the Supreme Court of India.