One of my clients recently had a case which I am explaining below and if you are stuck in such similar situation, here is what to do.
Note: Due to attorney-client privilege, I cannot disclose complete case details or identify the actual parties involved. However, I am sharing the essential facts and legal approach so that if you find yourself in a similar situation, you can understand the available solutions and legal remedies.
TL;DR: If the builder sold the flat to someone else after taking your booking advance, you have two routes running side by side: a civil or RERA claim asking for specific performance, refund and an injunction, and a criminal complaint for cheating. Move quickly. Once a registered sale deed exists in a third party's name, getting your own name on that flat becomes far harder.
The agreement named the flat. Third floor, 3BHK, in a project coming up on the edge of Jaipur. Mr. Ankit Jain paid ₹25 lakh as advance, ₹20 lakh to one partner of the developer firm and ₹5 lakh to the second partner. Receipts were issued for both. Nobody thought much about the fact that the money had gone into two different accounts.
Months later, a neighbour mentioned that the same flat had been shown to another family. Mr. Jain called Partner B, the one who had taken the smaller amount. No answer. He called again and again. Partner B's phone rang out. The neighbour's words stayed with Mr. Jain: the same flat, shown to another family. That was all he had. No sale deed in front of him. No written cancellation. Just a flat he thought was his, and a man who had stopped picking up. He came to the chamber. We only have his side of this. The developer has not been heard. That matters, because the law turns on what the developer actually did and when.
What the law says when a builder sells the same flat twice
Under Indian law, booking a flat and paying an advance creates a legal relationship. It is not just a receipt. It is a contract. If the builder then sells that flat to someone else, the builder has breached that contract. That breach can be pursued in civil court and before the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA). Separately, if the builder took your money knowing there was no intention to deliver, or after already selling to another, it can amount to cheating under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
Two routes. They can run together, but they do different things. The civil or RERA route is about your money and your flat. The criminal route is about punishment for the builder's conduct. Neither replaces the other.
The civil and RERA route: specific performance, refund, injunction
You have three possible asks. First, specific performance: a court order compelling the builder to execute a sale deed in your favour. Second, refund: return of the advance with interest. Third, injunction: an order restraining the builder from creating further rights over that flat while the case is pending.
Specific performance is the strongest remedy if the flat still exists and the builder has not yet conveyed it to a third party. Under the Specific Relief Act, 1963, specific performance is now the rule, not the exception, for agreements involving immovable property. But it becomes difficult once a registered sale deed exists in someone else's name. That third party may be an innocent purchaser. The court then usually pushes you toward refund and damages.
RERA adds a parallel forum. Under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, an allottee can file a complaint before the state RERA authority seeking refund with interest, or possession, or both. RERA is often faster than a civil suit. But RERA cannot order specific performance in the same way a civil court can. It can direct the promoter to return the amount with interest and compensation.
Limitation: for civil suits, the limitation period is generally three years from the date the right to sue accrues. For RERA complaints, courts have applied the same three-year period by analogy. Do not sit on it.
The criminal route: cheating under BNS
If the builder took your advance and then sold the flat to another, or never had clear title, the conduct may fall under Section 318 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (cheating). The essential ingredient is dishonest intention at the time of inducement. If the builder took your money with no intention of delivering the flat, that is cheating. If it was a genuine dispute over scheduling, it may be a civil wrong only. The line is intention. That is why criminal complaints in builder cases often fail at the FIR stage unless there is clear evidence of dishonest intent from the start.
To file an FIR, you go to the police station with a written complaint. If the police refuse, you can approach the Superintendent of Police or the Magistrate under the BNSS, 2023. The procedure for information in cognizable cases is in Section 173 of the BNSS. For cheating under BNS, the punishment can extend to seven years and fine.
We only have one side. The developer might say the flat was never finally allotted, or that the advance was a token and the agreement was conditional. That would change the criminal analysis completely.
Key facts that decide these cases
- Was there a written agreement specifically naming the flat? (Here, yes: third floor, 3BHK, Jaipur project.)
- How much was paid and to whom? (Here, ₹25 lakh total: ₹20 lakh to one partner, ₹5 lakh to another.)
- Were receipts issued for each payment? (Here, yes.)
- Was the flat shown to another family, and if so, when? (Here, a neighbour mentioned it.)
- Has a sale deed been registered in a third party's name? (Here, not clear from the account.)
- Did the builder stop responding? (Here, calls went unanswered.)
What to do first, second, third
First, gather documents. The agreement, both receipts, bank statements showing the transfers, any WhatsApp messages or emails, and the neighbour's details if they will give a statement. Second, send a legal notice to both partners and the firm. A notice does two things: it creates a record, and it sometimes brings the builder to the table. Third, decide the forum. If you want the flat, file a civil suit for specific performance and injunction. If you want your money back with interest, RERA is often faster. You can file both, but you cannot recover twice for the same loss.
For the criminal complaint, do not wait for the civil case to finish. File the FIR or complaint before the Magistrate. But be aware: police often treat builder disputes as civil unless the cheating is obvious. A well-drafted complaint with dates, amounts, and the two-account payment detail helps.
What it costs in time
RERA complaints in many states take six months to two years. Civil suits for specific performance can take three to seven years, sometimes longer. Criminal cases can take years as well. The injunction, if granted early, is the fastest protective step. That is why the first hearing matters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I file both a RERA complaint and an FIR?
Yes. They are different proceedings. RERA is for recovery or possession. FIR is for punishment. One does not cancel the other. But you must tell the RERA authority and the police about both.
The builder says the advance was non-refundable. Does that end it?
No. A clause saying the advance is non-refundable does not allow the builder to sell the same flat to someone else and keep your money. That would be unjust enrichment. Courts have refused to enforce such clauses where the builder is the one in breach.
What if the flat is already registered in someone else's name?
Specific performance becomes very hard. The third party may be a bona fide purchaser for value without notice. Your remedy then usually shifts to refund with interest and damages. Sometimes you can challenge the sale deed if you can show the third party colluded with the builder, but that requires evidence.
How long do I have to file?
Generally three years from the date the cause of action arose, which is usually when the builder refused to deliver or sold to another. RERA and civil courts apply this. Do not wait for the builder to respond. File within time.
What should I bring to a lawyer?
The agreement, all receipts, bank statements, any communication with the builder, and a short timeline of what happened when. A two-line note is enough to start.
If you are in this situation, send me the agreement, the receipts, and a two-line note with the date of booking, the amount paid, and the name of the project. You can reach the chamber through contact us or book a consultation. The first step is to check whether a sale deed has already been registered. That single fact decides most of the strategy.
This is general information, not legal advice on your own situation. Every case turns on its own documents and dates.
Advocate Sudhir Rao, Supreme Court of India